Symmetry recognition by pigeons: Generalized or not?
نویسندگان
چکیده
This note looks into the reasons why earlier reports may have arrived at differing conclusions about pigeons' capacity to categorize bilaterally symmetric and asymmetric visual patterns. Attention is drawn to pigeons' comparatively superior visual flicker resolution and superior visual linear acuity by reporting results of two ad-hoc experiments. This circumstance turns out to constrain conclusions drawn by earlier symmetry-asymmetry studies that used computer-generated patterns displayed on cathode ray tube monitors as these suffered from pictorial distortions. Additionally one of the studies involved patterns of inconsistent symmetry at global and local levels. A smaller-scale experiment using slide-projected unequivocal symmetric and asymmetric patterns yielded results compatible with the supposition that pigeons are capable of a symmetry-asymmetry categorization. The possibility that an artfactual cue may have inadvertently accentuated this capability in an earlier own experiment is considered.
منابع مشابه
Visual symmetry recognition by pigeons.
Pigeons learned to discriminate a large number of bilateral symmetric and asymmetric visual patterns successively projected on the pecking-key of an operant conditioning chamber. Responses to the positive stimuli were reinforced according to a variable interval schedule. Once acquisition was complete generalization trials, involving sets of new stimuli, were instituted under extinction. The bir...
متن کاملEmergent identity but not symmetry following successive olfactory discrimination training in rats.
The search for symmetry in nonhuman subjects has been successful in recent studies in pigeons (e.g., Urcuioli, 2008). The key to these successes has been the use of successive discrimination procedures and combined training on identity, as well as arbitrary, baseline relations. The present study was an effort to extend the findings and theoretical analysis developed by Urcuioli and his colleagu...
متن کاملConcurrent identity training is not necessary for associative symmetry in successive matching.
Pigeons demonstrate associative symmetry after successive matching training on one arbitrary and two identity relations (e.g., Urcuioli, 2008). Here, we tested whether identity matching training is necessary for this emergent effect. In Experiment 1, one group of pigeons (Dual Oddity) learned hue-form arbitrary matching and two oddity relations which shared sample and comparison elements with t...
متن کاملAn examination of the temporal and spatial stimulus control in emergent symmetry in pigeons
If an organism is explicitly taught an A B association, then might it also spontaneously learn the symmetrical B A association? There is only a small amount of evidence that attests to the detection of emergent symmetry in nonhuman animals (e.g., one chimpanzee and two pigeons). This dissertation examines the necessary and sufficient conditions for finding emergent symmetry in pigeons while att...
متن کاملVisual control of an action discrimination in pigeons.
Recognizing and categorizing behavior is essential for all animals. The visual and cognitive mechanisms underlying such action discriminations are not well understood, especially in nonhuman animals. To identify the visual bases of action discriminations, four pigeons were tested in a go/no-go procedure to examine the contribution of different visual features in a discrimination of walking and ...
متن کامل